294 PAINTING MATERIALS Probably many different hard stones were adopted by painters for this pur- pose, but porphyry seems to have been a favorite since the Middle Ages. Thomp- son (The Practice of Tempera Painting, pp. 88-89) says that porphyry or granite are still the best materials for slabs and mullers but that glass is a simple substi- tute. This or marble has to be resurfaced when it gets smooth and that can be done with moderately fine emery powder, wetted, and ground between muller and slab. Sir Aurel Stein (Serindia, I, 772) reports the discovery at Tun Huang in Chinese Turkestan of a wooden block which he thought had been used as a grind- ing slab. It was D-shaped in section, and one end and the adjacent side still had wrappings of linen. On it was thick, black paint. A second similar block was found in the same site. No mention has appeared in the technical literature of the color- grinding methods used by ancient Egyptians, but it can be assumed that the hard mineral pigments, particularly the well known Egyptian blue, must have been ground on a slab or in a mortar. One indication of such a utensil is seen in the British Museum. It is a piece of dark stone about seven inches across, rather flat on the bottom, rounded at the edges, circular in plan, and less than half as thick as its diameter. The top has a shallow, saucer-shaped depression. This seems to be Egyptian and is something between a mortar and a grinding slab. Little is known about other ancient practices of preparing paints, but an anecdote by Pliny (XXXV, 85) suggests that in the studio of Apelles there were boys who ground the colors. By the early Middle Ages in Europe, the fairly standard equipment of the painter's work-room appears to have been a heavy slab mounted on a heavy block. The MS. of Theophilus speaks of it, as does that of Eraclius (see Laurie, The Painter's Methods and Materials, pp. 25 and 27). Cennino Cennini mentions porphyry (C. XLII, Thompson, p. 25) and so does the author of the much later Brussels MS. in 1635 (Merrifield, II, 770). By the XVII century there are many representations of the grinding tables or blocks, usually with circular or polyg- onal, heavy slabs. The hand-grinding of colors undoubtedly continued long after fairly large- scale commercial manufacture was developed, and some amount of it is still done by artists' colormen or by painters themselves. In the early XIX century, a form of hand-operated color mill was developed, and shortly after that a larger mill with stones propelled by hand, horse, or steam power. The common modern mill is operated by a motor and is of rotating cylinders. Water colors, as first manufactured for sale, were usually in small, hard cakes which, like the Far Eastern ink stick, had to be ground with water on a small slab in order to bring the color out into the fluid. Such grinding material and equipment were sold commonly after the middle of the century and, although little mentioned or advertised, can still be bought. Hog Hair, the name formerly applied to the heavier artists* brush, now usually referred to as bristle (see Brush).