MEDIUMS AND ADHESIVES 57 a natural inference, for pitch and crude varnish were used in ship-building, and the Egyptians used pure resins. The only historical reference, however, is made by Pliny (John, p. 36), who, in speaking of Apelles, tells how that artist covered his pictures with a layer of ' atramentum.' This was evidently some kind of a varnishing process; the layer was said to be so transparent that, while it did not affect the colors and served to protect them from dust, it was invisible, except under close examination. According to Pliny, no one was able to imitate this process. It is hard to understand why there were difficulties, for, from Pliny's intimations, it can be assumed that the varnish was a semi-liquid resin, dissolved in a little fluid bitumen. He lists resins obtained from many varieties of pine and others from Syria and Africa, such as mastic and terebinth; but, although resins dissolved in olive oil were used pharmaceutically, there is no mention of a varnish being prepared in this way. Varnishes that can be applied with a brush require the use of a thinner or of a solvent, The solvent power of turpentine was known as early as 460 B.C. and was referred to by Pliny, but apparently spirits of turpentine, or other volatile thinners, were not employed in the manufacture of varnish. Historical records about resins and their use in varnish making up to the XVIII century are largely recipes and statements of early writers. These have to do with oil varnishes, but it is often impossible to know the exact nature of the resin called for. The term,c amber,' was used to cover a great variety of hard resins, and it referred often to their color regardless of their origin. In the same way, * mastic' and ' sandarac' are used indiscriminately, and other resins are , called by names which are difficult to identify today. Many of the varnish recipes given in the Lucca MS. in the VIII century and those given during the following centuries, however, may be interpreted in the light of present knowledge about the resins probably available at those times. Both mastic and sandarac were used and many pine balsams were known. Of the hard resins, amber was certainly obtainable at an early date, and African copals probably could be found in the markets. Barry (p. 44) quotes Fr. Stuhlman (Deutsch Ost. Afrika) as believing that the trade in copals began as early as the X century when Arabs exchanged it with the Indians for cotton fabric. From isolated statements it appears to have been used in the XVI century, but it is not mentioned to any extent until the latter half of the XVIII century. The Lucca MS. (Berger, III, 15) describes the preparation of a varnish by dissolving resin in linseed oil, and one recipe, de lucide ad lucidas, calls for amber, mastic, three kinds of turpentine, resin, galbanum, myrrh, two gums, a little linseed oil, and florae puppli. This would make an extremely stiff varnish which, while still hot, would have to be rubbed onto the picture. Here there is confusion again about the term, amber. True amber could only have been dissolved by first fusing the turpentines and by adding the amber before the oil. Several recipes call for a hard resin, and, although this is called * glassa * or' karabe,' and has, therefore, been assumed to be amber,